The solution heer is to head to Admin > DKP > Quick Edit Destinations, and change the ratio for Non-Members to match the others. Give that a shot, and lemme know if that doesn't work for you.

Interesting. I went and corrected those numbers and I think that will fix it, but why wouldn't the general point assignment for the boss not override the per rank numbers? We actually vary points each week based on different factors so we don't use the per rank assignment defaults and instead enter in the general override each time we upload.

Edit: Well actually will that fix it? If the default for all of those ranks is 1, and I this week I import and award 3 as the general override, which will take precedence? Does that mean that some will get the 3 from the override but some like non-members get just 1?

The Per-rank stuff isn't a number, it's a ratio. So, if it's 0, members with that rank will received 0% of the assigned points for that boss. If it's 1, then that's 100%.

If you had it set to 0.25 for non-members, for example, and you had a boss where you awarded 40 points per attendee, and one of your attendees were new (no character on the site), then it will give that member 10 points, rather than the 40. (40 * 25% = 10)

Make sense? It's a ratio, not a straight point assignment.

Some guilds prefer to give less points to initiates or whatnot, while they are probationary, and then when they are promoted to full member, they receive full DKP.