Actually...
With advanced layout you can just reproduce the Main Menu and include only those links you want (after all Main Menu links to specific locations and isn't really dynamic).
It is even easier than that and if implemented by Chops the way I am thinking and describing would be done entirely without an Advanced Layout for those that are not web savvy.
In the Basic Menu Administration you can remove the Online Application from the Main Menu.
Then if you go to Static Menus and Content you can create a separate menu for the Application and make the link to the application so that it opens in the main page when clicked.
you would need Chops option the IfRankElse to hide the menu from members though or change the options on the Static Menus and Content page to allow for a show to rank X and above or X and below assuming the mechanism was built such that if you chose Everyone there is no one below everyone so only non members would see it. Or just make a Hide from members option.