The problem for you, Isara, is that it's missing in the template definition. You guys are running a custom template.
You'll want to add the following to the <Head> section of your layout file:
<link rel=icon href="http://dkpfiles.com/synergyrh/icon">
<link rel="shortcut icon" href="http://dkpfiles.com/synergyrh/icon">
Your template is also missing that, Shianne, though that is largely my fault for missing it in the original Drop-In Template.
If you were to add that to the <Head> section of your template as well (changing synergyrh to taintedeq2), you'd be good to go.